In the course of a few weeks at work, I have been officially told some things, unofficially told some things, and noticed a few things about how civil rights work over here. As I learn more, I will probably come back to this topic as it is culturally interesting, I think, to consider how another "free country" decides what rights belong to the individual.
Firearms:The differences in laws governing firearms, are so different as to hardly be interesting. The "right" to bear arms, basically doesn't exist here. With proper credentials, one can own a couple of guns for hunting purposes and some target shooting. According to my landlord, it takes nearly two years to get the credentials, although I suspect this is a bit of an exageration. If you think requiring a permit to carry a concealed weapon is draconian, Germany is not for you. And, for that matter, neither is a lot of Europe.
In talking with my coworkers, it is clear that the idea of even handling a gun makes them uncomfortable. The idea that someone on the street in America could legally carry a concealed handgun seems insane to most Germans. It is also very unlikely in Germany that someone with nefarious intentions on the street is carrying either. One of my labmates who has lived in the States twice told me in no uncertain terms that the possible presence of firearms is one of the things that made him most uncomfortable with life there. His cultural bias is large and, as one might expect, his actual knowlege of firearms is quite low. It is interesting to note that from his perspective, firearm rights are not in anyway philosophically or fundamentally a prerequisite for freedom. He sees his fear and America's obsession as purely cultural, like Mao disagreeing with the Soviets about how to be a real communist.
Identification and the right to have your privacy invaded for no reason:Identification here is taken very seriously. You must not leave home without it, as any police officer, with NO probable cause, can ask you to identify yourself. I watched this happen on Friday at the train station. There is no ambiguity about what is meant by "identification". The national ID card is the only thing that can satisfy this requirement. That card is basically the first page of the German passport, but laminated individually. I have been issued such a card (sondernausweis), but mine is different from a German citizen's and also not like most foreign worker's. Because I work at EMBL, which isn't technically in Germany, I have a diplomatic sondernausweis and like everyone here, I have to carry it all of the time. Of course, the thing is about 10% too big to go in my wallet. I may have to breakdown and get a European man purse, just to lug the thing around. Apparetnly, a stolen one of these diplomatic sondernausweis is almost as valuable as an American passport.
Furthermore, the police here will occasionally set up random checkpoints on the road and stop cars, again with no probable cause. My coworkers have all been through these things at one time or another. During these stops the police expect you to identify yourself, and also prove that you own the vehicle, that its inspecition is up to date, that the necessary work was performed on the car following the last inspection, and that you have the proper tires on the vehicle for the season. Additionally, everyone in the car must also be able to identify themselves. My American friend here jokes that if you have your dog is in the vehicle, the police will make you prove that you own it, that its shots are up to date and that you paid the dog tax.
This situation causes some difficult situations for people who work up at EMBL who aren't from Germany and therefore have the diplomatic version of the ID. I have been repeatedly warned that if I am stopped in such a situation as described above, to expect to be delayed considerably because my type of diplomatic sondernausweis is rarely seen outside of the capital and hence the police tend to not trust it. I could also carry my passport, but this comes with the dual worry of theft/loss and the possibility of damaging it. An American friend of mine at work was similarly warned and carried his passport and eventually it got pretty dog eared from riding around in his pocket all of the time. As a result he was prevented from re-entering Germany, as they thought the beat up passport had gotten that way because it was stolen and taken apart to change the picture.
So you might wonder why the Germans put up with what at the very least is quite an inconvenience. My labmates love to compare here (Germany) to over there (the States) so I have heard a few opinions on this now. Some say they see it, more or less, like an audit that keeps people honest. Others say that it is necessary since the opening of the iron curtain and because of the free movement now allowed in the EU. They argue that this type of policy is tolerated to make it easier to catch immigrants in the country illegaly, basically trading some privacy for the protection from immigrants leaching off of the strong German economy, which is a little wobbly right now. I don't know how much I buy the former, but judging from the strict requirements for citizenship, it is easy to believe the latter.
Mom, she won't stop touching me:This is a very touchy area over here and I have been told several different things as to how to respond, say if someone is mugging you. I hadn't even thought of this, but then we had an experience on the bus here that made me consider how I might respond.
Actually paying for a bus ticket is on the honor system and then occasionally these guys with meter maid like duties will get on a bus and check tickets and write 40 Euro tickets to the Schwarzfarhers (black riders, cute hmm?) who don't have the right ticket. As you might imagine, these guys (the bus cops, not the Schwarzfahrers) try to look like everyone else and conceal their identity, otherwise they are easily evaded. (Even incognito, we evaded them once, in a brush with two 40 Euro fines, but that is a story for another post.)
So, I saw one of these bus cops come to the door of a stopped bus and actually physically impede someone from exiting the bus by grabbing his upper arm. While it may be my American prejudice combined with my American hot headedness, I thought this guy looked pretty much like a thug and if he had done this to me, my first impulse would have been to shake free and get the hell out of there. Or if he had grabbed Rachel, I might have just punched him. Notice that I didn't mention that the bus cop ever identified himself to this person, because he didn't. His first action was to make physical contact.
I asked my coworkers, German and otherwise, about this incident. They assured me that it shouldn't work this way but said that occasionally they too have seen the bus cops get pretty aggressive with someone. The Germans also said that Heidelberg is a bit notorious for hiring some pretty scummy guys on short contracts when they decide they have to crack down on the Schwarzfahrers, which I believe was going on that weekend. Most of the time the bus cops are pretty reasonable.
This made me think a little bit and ask my coworkers about how to respond in a situation where you feel your safety may be in danger and I got some interesting advice. Some of them said, "The guy almost certainly will not have a gun, or even a knife, so fight back. Hold on to your stuff. If you don't let go, they will after a minute." I was warned by another colleague that whatever you do, don't do anything that could be made to look like assault. Even if you are being mugged, if no one else sees it, you could be in for a world of hurt in both criminal and civil court if you hurt someone and then can't prove that you were being mugged. Hitting people just isn't allowed.
Which leads to some interesting behavior. Despite what you hear about the Germans being reserved and not prone to outbursts of passion, we have seen some real wild arguments take place in very public places. For instance, a 70 year old fellow gets on the bus and a youngish Turk is sitting in the front seat. The elder says to the younger,"Get out of my #$% seat you no good #$%$%& Turk." As you might imagine a yelling match insues which includes phrases that this keyboard doesn't have symbols for (and I don't mean that I need a lot of umlauts). Some of my coworkers feel like the nastiness of such interactions escalates so quickly because no matter what is said, everyone knows that violence will never erupt. It is simply to risky to involve yourself in something like that.